Skip to content

Comment on A New Physics Theory of Lifeparent

Comments

One explination is that consciousness is beyond matter. Since modern science is only concerned with material universe, it cannot explain consciousness.

There is, however, a science, which asserts that every human being can understand consciousness and experience it as separate from the matter if he attempts. Read Raja Yoga by Swami Vivekananda if you are really curious.

Where did you get this idea that science only deals with matter?

Science is the discipline of publicly testing ideas by systematic observation, controlled experiment and Bayesian inference. Notice there is no mention of "matter" in that definition.

If an idea has any consequences it can be tested by practicing the discipline of science. If an idea is consequence-free it is boring. Ideas about consciousness that are fully decoupled from material consequences are boring: they entail that no human action is caused by consciousness. For example, my consciousness would have to be unrelated to the contents of this message, because it was generated by making various bits of matter move.

Material consequences are the most studied by science because they are the easiest to get at and they have the widest scope, but we use them to study immaterial and abstract causes all the time.

I mentioned that modern science deals with the matter, and not science because science itself is an abstract term.

Here by matter or material includes even ideas and inference because they all stem from mind and mind is built of subtlest matter (as per Samkhya philosophy upon which Raja Yoga is based).

The method to experience of consciousness in Raja Yoga is not consequence free – direct experience of ones own consciousness is the best experience a man can have, and it transforms him thereafter forever. Also read Kundalini by Gopi Krishna.

The process itself is far from boaring and you'll be surprised the changes/experiences you start to observe within few weeks/months of starting the enquiry. (But beware of scammers who sell trademark techniques!)

Btw, I'm not professing any religion here. It's just that there's a method of enquiry which many people throughout the history have attempted and they have experienced something which you also can provided that you dare to. (Samkhya philosophy in fact denies existence of God as we know it but only professes idea of pure consciousness)

Swamij.com is also a good read for curious folks. I have been researching and practicing for some time. I have good number of proofs which modern science has recognized, plus my experiences of last few months. I plan to write an article on this some day. .

Insofar as consciousness has an impact on the material world, it falls under the domain of science. Science deals with causality, and if something is in a causal relationship with the universe, it can be studied.

I think you'll find that that's not, in fact, a science. It's a philosophy at best, and a religion at worst.

There's a science [0], and there's a step-by-step method if you really want to follow. And no it doesn't require you to visit temples or do rituals rather just like science, it requires you to observe, experiment and be patient with your body and mind so that you can eventually experience the third, consciousness.

0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8753204

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.