Skip to content

Comment on Google Launching Its Cloud Service Tomorrow, Without Big Music's Approvalparent

Comments

Magnatune isn't a big label, but it's DRM-free and splits 50/50 with the artists. It's also non-exclusive, so the artists can make deals with others as well, if they like. Their "end-user" license lets each subscriber give 3 friends a copy of the music.

I'm not familiar with the industry, but is 50/50 split considered good?

IIRC, the major label deal goes like this:

  * Major label gives artist a loan for $X to cover the costs of
    producing the album.
  * Artists earn back something like 12% on album sales (though I
    believe 12% is on the high end).
  * That 12% goes directly towards paying back the loan for the
    production of the album.
  * Artists don't retain the copyrights to their works (at least the
    recordings, they may retain copyright to the lyrics, depending on
    the contract/studio).
  * Artists don't give a cut of merchandise sales, or ticket sales for
    live shows.
  * Artists retain the copyrights to recordings of live performances,
    which is how bands like Grateful Dead or Dave Matthews can allow
    'bootleg' recordings of their live shows.
  * The studio retains rights to copyrights of live shows that are
    professionally recorded for the purposes of putting out a 'live'
    album though.
  * Most artists are never able to pay back the initial loan to create
    the album.

The other side:

* Major label advances an unknown artist a bunch of money.

* Album sells poorly.

* Artist never pays back advance.

* Major label would have been better not making the deal.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.