Skip to content

Comment on Yahoo, Bucking Industry, Scans Emails for Data to Sell Advertisersparent

Comments

Who said they were gathering less data? Do you understand how an email mailbox works? Those emails are still there, just like they are with any other email service.

The parent comment that I replied to:

Google actually reverted its policy on the issue and has since stopped collecting data from user email content

So the 'who' would be the parent commenter.

Do you understand how an email mailbox works?

That type of comment feels so out of place here. I've clearly deeply annoyed you, but it's hard to tell from your reply what exactly your issue is.

The issue is people not understanding the difference between data collection and data use for one or more purposes. This sloppy thinking (which to my mind is so obviously wrong that I can't understand how anyone would think it) shows up repeatedly on this forum, and you're just the latest example. My apologies.

Once the data is collected, it can be used at some later date for any purpose whatsoever. It's up to the user to decide if they like the purposes it is being used for today and if they either think the data will be used for purposes they like in the future or will be able to migrate their data off the service.

Once the data is collected, it can be used at some later date for any purpose whatsoever.

INAL, but I'm fairly confident you cannot unless you want to get lawsuit. Granted, the terms that practically nobody looks at give companies pretty far reaching grants on how they can use the data but that does not mean they can change the terms on old data that was collected under a previous contract.

I work with personally identifiable information and I have to get approval from a privacy team and a lawyer team to utilize data in any new way because of said contracts.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.