Skip to content

Comment on Using BitTorrent with Amazon S3

Comments

Just moved a bunch of our company's large downloads over to S3 recently (mostly BSP releases and drivers), and this would be awesome for that 100MB - 4GB package size range that they have!

Tried it with a few clients: Transmission does not seem to work, though (both web client, and GTK): "Tracker gave HTTP response code 404..."; rtorrent seems to be able to download (but looks like no upload?); deluge downloads well and also kickstarts the transmission clients.

I wonder what's unacceptable in the Amazon infrastructure for transmission... And the 80kb/s max seed rate mentioned in the comments might be a showstopper already.

A couple of months ago I tested with Transmission (on a Mac) and it worked fine. The problem from my point of view was that the S3 side only seeded at 50-100 KB/sec, but if I downloaded directly from S3 I could pull 2MB/sec.

Unless you have a bunch of seeds, that are essentially permanent, it's pretty useless.

Might still be useful as a seeder of last resort to borrow done finance terminology. Ie back a large number of say community nix isos with it.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.