Skip to content

Comment on Ask HN: What's your experience with the new macbook?parent

Comments

Wait, how is this first generation? Do you consider any refresh of an existing line to be "first generation"? What would you consider not to be "first generation".

The computers that are processor bumps aren't first generation. Not the case here; though this is a similar computer to the MacBook Air, there are a ton of new parts in it. The Air is still (more or less) the same design that it's had since 2010 or so.

As an example, Apple had been making white iBooks for a long time before their Intel transition. But the 1st gen MacBook used a different white plastic that could absorb oils from your hands and turn a nice shade of orange/brown. http://appleinsider.com/articles/06/07/26/apple_recognizes_w...

With a brand new design, you risk problems like that slipping through the cracks. Maybe it turns out that the new keyboard mechanism starts missing presses once the usual crud falls in between the keys, or maybe the USB-C connector isn't durable enough and stops charging reliably a few months in. If the new models have any issues like that, waiting for the second version would save you some headaches.

Newer form factor. Newer port. Newer keyboard. Newer battery tech. Lots of new things to the Macbook line.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.