Skip to content

Comment on Scientists Seek Ban on Method of Editing the Human Genomeparent

Comments

Genetics could improve the inequality situation too, but that would require challenging elements of our economic system which is off the table.

No it couldn't, and in any case that are infinitely more direct and efficient ways of addressing inequality if that is truly your goal.

There are more direct and efficient ways of addressing inequality than genetically changing people to be equal?

I mean, really? Poverty correlates far more strongly with negative health outcomes, lower educational attainment, increased risk of incarceration, unhappiness, decreased life expectancy--you name it--than any known genetic risk factor.

Forgot an "almost". There are some terrible hereditary diseases. But the point remains.

So if everyone were clones that would not be enough equality for you?

How would you go about your further goals in this clone society? Constant monitoring of citizens, tracking their lives, measuring disparities in the short and long term and either awarding or punishing certain activities at certain times by certain people to make sure everything is equal to everyone?

Seriously, what do you mean by equality that the ability to choose one's genes wouldn't fix?

Haha. I sensed this thread starting to take a turn towards nutcase-ville... aaaand here we are. If you really believe that there is absolutely no daylight between a) lessening pervasive, endemic inequality that exists the status quo and b) "1984 with clones", well, that says a lot about you and your world view. #ocra

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.