Skip to content

Comment on Remembering My Cousin, Ludwig Wittgenstein (1977)

Comments

The episode with the poker-assisted demonstration of the "simplicity of matter" could probably be interpreted as an expression of Wittgenstein's belief that metaphysics (which presumably a discussion of the nature of matter would constitute) could not be meaningfully discussed in words. When it comes to metaphysics (and other "nonsense": poetry, ethics), "show, don't tell."

This is how, for example, Janik and Toulmin's book Wittgenstein's Vienna, explain his obsession with Westerns (the film genre, not the people): they show what cannot be said about morality in their depiction of good, evil, loyalty, etc. Talk of "the simplicity of matter" would be nonsense, but we can definitely get something across by vigorously swinging a poker around. (There is general agreement, I believe, that Wittgenstein significantly revised his stance on what can be meaningfully said/done in language between the Tractatus and Philosophical Investigations in the 50s.)

On the other hand, maybe he was just angry (he "threatened" Karl Popper with a poker during a philosophical disagreement).

Take all of this with a grain of salt, I am not a Wittgenstein expert.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.