Skip to content

Comment on Dropbox Is Probably Not Stealing Your Files

Comments

"This is, by necessity, a system-wide process."

This is, by design, a fucking huge defect of the underlying system calls.

Give the OS a list of folders to watch. Dropbox should not even get a callback for a file it's not is supposed to watch.

You can constrain filesystem callbacks on Windows, I have no idea why Dropbox doesn't.

See: inotify in Linux

inotify is by far the best of the filesystem notification APIs. It's wildly reasonable.

Exactly - how much information can be inferred from the file and path alone - in a lot of my cases (for very personal files), quite a lot.

If Dropbox gets to interpose itself in every file update systemwide, that sounds like it's getting too much of my information. Encrypted/Stego drives don't matter - once you open it up to the system, Dropbox sees when you touch it.

All I can gather from this discussion is that I'm glad I'm not using Windows and Dropbox together.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.