Skip to content

Comment on KaTeX: Math typesetting for the web

Comments

Props to the coders for improving upon the LaTeX/Web use case space, but I can't help but feel something other than LaTeX is going to be necessary for the internet. LaTeX was fundamentally about document-level typesetting, and the internet is fundamentally not a place where that happens.

Well, I think for the use case most people use it for on the web, embedding a few equations in a web page, it's just fine, because everyone who writes about math already knows LaTeX. It doesn't really matter that no one is actually doing document-level typesetting on the web. It may be idiosyncratic in some ways but it's just too common to replace IMO.

I suppose by "internet" you mean "web" and in particular the fundamental problem you see is that LaTeX assumes the input contains everything needed for the final output, whereas hypertext on the web can be remixed in an open-ended way? I.e., it's hard to get pleasing results out of a process of composition of disparate LaTeX sources?

Otherwise could you clarify the conflict you have in mind?

Minimal example: LaTeX embedding as practiced on the web doesn't reflow. TeX was intended for documents that knew their width, height, margins and etc.; no guarantees in a web page.

Well, TeX hasn't been used much for whole web page generation. For math however, it is uncontended.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.