Skip to content

Comment on Atom Now Available on Windows

Comments

Remind me again, this is what, compared to Emacs?

People argue it is very similar to Sublime, but is open source, thus has higher community support and promising future.

I would not compare Atom to emacs or vim. On the other hand, Windows always frustrated me of low text editors choice, Atom might quickly earn its name on Windows platform.

So far I'm having a hard time discerning its value over the Windows release of Geany. I'm not saying that it doesn't have that value, I'm just struggling to find it. Having said that, choice is generally perceived to be a good thing.

I use and like Geany on Linux. GTK apps on Windows have always been buggy for me though. Geany had a strange issue where it would sometimes maximize larger than the screen, so the only way to get control of the window again was WindowsKey+DownArrow.

I also have trouble finding nice themes for Geany.

Sublime and Notepad++ are much more polished, but I plan on giving Atom a legitimate trial now that there's an official build.

Atom has some Emacs-like qualities. See for example a game for destroying the window contents: https://atom.io/packages/asteroids This is the kind of thing we saw in emacs.

It's very similar: a notepad application with keyboard shortcuts. Good when cannot afford/access a proper IDE.

Good when cannot afford/access a proper IDE.

Or when you don't want one of those at all.

I guess, although this sort of editors tend to mutate into a semi-IDE in their later stages:

https://sublime.wbond.net/browse/popular

Currently full of Bugs, Emacs not! Currently supports a few OS, Emacs supports a lot's! It's is slow, Emacs not! <and so on>

Ok the list is full but i'm not really sure about Atom. Maybe it could replace ST in the future, since the developer is away. But i guess to take Emacs or Vim will take much more time. Atom is simply not ready yet for production.

Which noone claimed to begin with.

editor that doesn't loose cursor position when scrolling.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.