Skip to content

Comment on The “Stolen” Mt. Gox Data Contained Malware That Robbed Users Of Bitcoinparent

Comments

Aren't you reinventing app sandboxes here?

That's a good question - why don't modern consumer OSes offer simple, convenient one-click app sandboxing?

Because programs operate on files which need to be accessible by other programs. This is the whole point of files with interoperable file formats.

The applications that does not do this, i.e. games, are good candidates for sandboxing, but normal applications? Not so much.

Well, you could include the standard file operations (launch program by doubleclicking that file, save that particular file; secure "save-as" selection provided by OS) as managed parts of the sandbox; and have a functional app that is unable to open&change any files that the user doesn't intentionally choose.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.