Multithreading in GL does not work consistently. If you ask the driver vendors (AMD, NVIDIA, etc) they will tell you it doesn't work at all or across platforms. If you ask engine developers (like Valve) they will tell you in talks that it doesn't work across platforms.
What's cross platform? I guess what matters in this specific argument is feature parity with D3D on all the platforms it can compete on.
If it works on Windows, then I wonder if it really matters. I've seen a lot of games (e.g. Team Fortress 2) still offer multithreading as an option in the UI, so there's already two code paths there.
I have been told by driver vendors that GL multithreading does not work on windows, yes.
D3D multithreading works (even, to a lesser extent, with D3D9!), and this is one of the reasons why our D3D9 renderer is dramatically faster than our GL one - we can offload a subset of rendering work to helper threads instead of keeping it all locked on the thread that owns the window.
TF2/etc do offer a multithreaded rendering option, but IIRC on Windows their engine still uses D3D. Also, note that it's an option, because the feature used to be very unstable (still might be, actually) - I suspect people using the GL version of those games may have to disable it on certain hardware/driver configurations.
Comments
Multithreading in GL does not work consistently. If you ask the driver vendors (AMD, NVIDIA, etc) they will tell you it doesn't work at all or across platforms. If you ask engine developers (like Valve) they will tell you in talks that it doesn't work across platforms.
What's cross platform? I guess what matters in this specific argument is feature parity with D3D on all the platforms it can compete on.
If it works on Windows, then I wonder if it really matters. I've seen a lot of games (e.g. Team Fortress 2) still offer multithreading as an option in the UI, so there's already two code paths there.
I have been told by driver vendors that GL multithreading does not work on windows, yes.
D3D multithreading works (even, to a lesser extent, with D3D9!), and this is one of the reasons why our D3D9 renderer is dramatically faster than our GL one - we can offload a subset of rendering work to helper threads instead of keeping it all locked on the thread that owns the window.
TF2/etc do offer a multithreaded rendering option, but IIRC on Windows their engine still uses D3D. Also, note that it's an option, because the feature used to be very unstable (still might be, actually) - I suspect people using the GL version of those games may have to disable it on certain hardware/driver configurations.