As codez says, I agree you could benefit from simplifying the design of the site.

I really dislike that you are completely focused on one thing, and then you suddenly hide that thing from me and show me other things I should click on. It's jarring, and dare I say inconsiderate. It's like those horrible ads that block content you're reading and force you to close.

I'd take a solid look at a clean design that shows the user a main bit of content for that day, and maybe a few other things they can click on.

Take a page from upworthy. They do a nice job of not overloading the user with too many choices to click on.