Skip to content

Comment on Electric cars may hold solution for power storageparent

Comments

The primary issue of grid stabilization isn't supplying large amounts of energy to the grid over time, it's getting enough power to it right now. Highly responsive storage is a tremendous asset.

I've got my doubts over the viability of EV-based grid storage, and a lot of the viability depends on technologies. If we see a period of rapid charging carbon nanotube or graphene batteries which can literally be fully charged in seconds to minutes, and have a tremendous number of charge cycles, it starts looking more viable. Even a Tesla Supercharger situation is pretty good in terms of time -- few commuters will be inconvenienced if their vehicle only receives a net charge for the last 30 minutes of its idle cycle, which during a daytime commute scenario typically lasts 8-9 hours.

Presently the alternatives are ... few. Pumped hydro works but is very limited by available siting. There simply aren't that many places where you can run a pump/turbine between two large bodies of water with a significant grade separation, and far fewer in Kansas (or Illinois, or Florida for that matter). One of the more reactive alternatives is kinetic storage through flywheels, which offer tremendous charge/discharge rates, but are also very pricey: about $10,000 per kWh capacity

http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/09/got-storage-how-...

I suspect idle EVs will be at best a small part of the total solution, but even a few-percent solution could be meaningful.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.