Skip to content

Comment on Facebook is the 21st century tech equivalent of cigarettes

Comments

And this article is the 21st century article equivalent of cigarettes.. Both will give you cancer.

First off, he uses his personal google results, in incognito mode you wouldn't get these results (and you don't get anything related to facebook at all with this search query). Second, the term "How to quit facebook" isn't the same as "How to quit smoking" since "How to quit facebook" could be asking how to delete an account (which has nothing to do with addiction.) Third, there is a bias towards technology when using google search, things dealing with technology and especially the web will ALWAYS be higher up than searches relating to physical things, you can't use frequency of web searches as any type of statistic when comparing between a web based search and a physical based search.

So basically, this article is just as cancerous as cigarettes. Take it with a (HUGE) grain of salt.

The Google search is only mentioned once in passing in the text, and in the image.

Their argument is based on the number of users/groups on lift. This is of course, also pretty flimsy - but I don't think its being presented as scientifically rigorous; just as an observation that many people are trying to give up Facebook (and apparently having some trouble).

I think that your reply is a bit extreme.

The Google argument is mentioned once, and is not what led me to the conclusion. I found it while I was searching for an image to add to the post.

Most people that I know who deleted their Facebook account did it because they were wasting too much time on it. This is my subjective experience and opinion.

Sorry for giving you cancer.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.