The main page is pretty slick, though you might want to think about using at least slightly different styles for the "Considering" and "Looking for" sections.
The "get a bigger crowd" options are a really good idea.
However, the question/answer pages are rather crowded. A clearer seperation of elements would probably make it easier to see what's going on where. Also, the "Reason (intellect)" section has good functional elements for rating/feedback, but the "Attribute Ratings (feelings)" part doesn't. Why a drop down menu? That's an extra two clicks for every rating I want to give.
EDIT: And the "0" button for a 0 star rating doesn't feel intuitive and I don't see why it's even needed.
Thanks for the review. We are definitely looking to changing the consideration and looking for to be more aligned with terms being used on the site (Options and Attributes), and will try to make it more prominent.
We will look into re-working the UI for Attribute rating, I do agree that its extra clicks for something simple.
The reason for the "0" is to give something 0 stars, because in the system 0 has a negative value vs. not entering anything. Not entering a rating means you may not know about it to rate it. a "0" star means its bad. But, I see your point about how that can be confusing.
Comments
The main page is pretty slick, though you might want to think about using at least slightly different styles for the "Considering" and "Looking for" sections.
The "get a bigger crowd" options are a really good idea.
However, the question/answer pages are rather crowded. A clearer seperation of elements would probably make it easier to see what's going on where. Also, the "Reason (intellect)" section has good functional elements for rating/feedback, but the "Attribute Ratings (feelings)" part doesn't. Why a drop down menu? That's an extra two clicks for every rating I want to give.
EDIT: And the "0" button for a 0 star rating doesn't feel intuitive and I don't see why it's even needed.
Thanks for the review. We are definitely looking to changing the consideration and looking for to be more aligned with terms being used on the site (Options and Attributes), and will try to make it more prominent.
We will look into re-working the UI for Attribute rating, I do agree that its extra clicks for something simple.
The reason for the "0" is to give something 0 stars, because in the system 0 has a negative value vs. not entering anything. Not entering a rating means you may not know about it to rate it. a "0" star means its bad. But, I see your point about how that can be confusing.