A lot of this seems like mis-communication between a lawyer and a client. It sounds like people have talked to a lawyer. The lawyer says, "you need an NDA to talk with people about your business." The lawyer means for real negotiations about partnerships, etc. He never intends for it to be about semi-casual discussions about ideas. He is not in the tech business. "Talking about your business" to him means specific business strategies, pricing, bid and proposals, etc. And he crafted the NDA to cover these items.
A good alternative to "I'll never sign an NDA" is to counter with your own NDA that properly excludes the obvious. A good NDA, including ones that I have signed from major corporations, exclude information that has been made public in any way or that you hear from a third party. Or material that can be derived from public information.
That makes sense. But then you're into back and forth contracts in relation to your free gift of time and expertise. And once official rules are involved, relationship dynamics change.
Comments
A lot of this seems like mis-communication between a lawyer and a client. It sounds like people have talked to a lawyer. The lawyer says, "you need an NDA to talk with people about your business." The lawyer means for real negotiations about partnerships, etc. He never intends for it to be about semi-casual discussions about ideas. He is not in the tech business. "Talking about your business" to him means specific business strategies, pricing, bid and proposals, etc. And he crafted the NDA to cover these items.
A good alternative to "I'll never sign an NDA" is to counter with your own NDA that properly excludes the obvious. A good NDA, including ones that I have signed from major corporations, exclude information that has been made public in any way or that you hear from a third party. Or material that can be derived from public information.
That makes sense. But then you're into back and forth contracts in relation to your free gift of time and expertise. And once official rules are involved, relationship dynamics change.