Skip to content

Comment on Medium Sucks

Comments

I'd be interested in hearing some opinions from UX experts on the Medium interface?

Specifically:

* The rectangular 'M' in the top-left that hides a menu

* The inline hidden/comments that animate in on hover.

* The weird "suggest a link for further reading" functionality at the bottom of the article.

It really seems like a lot of confusing eye-candy to me and my assumption would be that it's cool/fun for a sophisticated technocrat, but the usability falls apart quickly after that.

Personally, I hate the inline commenting ideas. I read an article, and then scan the comments at the bottom. It seems pretty gratuitous to save the effort of "quoting" snippets to discuss.

I appreciate them thinking differently about things, though.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.