Skip to content

Comment on The Soviet Superplane Program That Rattled Area 51 (2011)

Comments

The ground effect increasing lift for these planes - is this similar to the cushion of air for the hyperloop?

I'll admit I don't know enough physics to really understand this, but they seem similar at first glance...

At the tips of the wings and at the trailing edge of the wings vortices will form when a wing is surrounded by nothing but air. Closer to the ground (typically less than a wingspan of the ground) these vortices start to form but are then interrupted by the ground. This results in an increase in lift and a very strong reduction in drag. The upshot of this is that in groundeffect a powered aircraft uses much less energy to move. Several bird species (mostly the bigger water birds) know how to exploit this as well.

The aircushion of the hyperloop is more like an air hockey table. It also reduces drag but that's drag from the surface of the table rather than from the air. Think of it as a two dimensional air bearing.

Apropos wingtip vortices: that's the reason lots of large planes are now equipped with winglets, these help to stop the formation of those vortices decreasing drag and increasing lift. Some larger windmill manufacturers use them too with the same goal, but in a windmill this translates to more power produced at the same windspeed rather than less fuel consumed in a vehicle.

The ground effect is just the effect that your wings are helped by the ground. The air pushes on the water. It is not air/air but air/ground (so the incompressibility of water helps you). With this effect the plane can flight even with these small wings.

Over water a plane in groundeffect will use slightly more energy than it would over land because even though water is incompressible that is effective only when it is completely constrained. Since water open to the environment at the top can be pushed inwards some of it will do that and this will cause a rise in the water just outside of the profile of the wings of the aircraft. Over a solid surface this would not happen. Similar to how riding a bicycle with springs costs more energy than one without.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.