Skip to content

Comment on Humble Bundle releases EA/Origin bundleparent

Comments

The involvement of Origin means this is really a loss leader.

The involvement of Origin is the reason why I am not picking up this bundle. Such a shame not all the games are available via Steam.

Why not pick up the bundle and only use the Steam keys? It's still a great deal...

I'm not the person to which you are replying, but as I have the same attitude I can at least answer for myself:

I already own the games that register on Steam that are interesting. I would only be interested in the games that don't register on Steam, but I do not want to use Origin.

I'm not sure what the big deal is. Clearly you aren't that interested in the games in the first place, and it's not really an Origin issue.

Steam has some pretty shitty policies as well, like the fact that you can no longer log in on multiple computers. This means you can't play two different games on the same account. Working backwards from the days when if you bought two games, two people could play them simultaneously.

Clearly you aren't that interested in the games in the first place, and it's not really an Origin issue.

Clearly how? You are correct that I am not sufficiently interested in order to go through the additional hassle of Origin. I have in the past been very interested in some games but did not want to add on the hassle of Origin and so I never got them. That's pretty much the same case as here.

Steam has some pretty shitty policies as well, like the fact that you can no longer log in on multiple computers.

It does but I don't find that relevant at all. For one, I have no need to log into multiple computers anyway. But for the more general case of Steam policies, I have found them a sufficient tradeoff for value. My issue with Origin is not strictly their policies but the fact that I already have Steam running with >500 games in my library and I don't want to be running Origin on top of that. It's unnecessary hassle and it's wasteful of resources.

If I got my buy-in on Origin first, odds are I'd be saying things the other way around.

I am really only interested in the Sims (I've never played any of them and am at least interested) which doesn't activate on Steam. It seems like you'd need to download Origin to get the game, which I am unwilling to do.

I wouldn't mind having Mirror's Edge but I loved the game so much that I burned myself out on the demo on PS3. I really love Burnout Paradise but already have it for PS3 (and am unlikely to put anymore time into it from scratch).

Not every game has a steam key on there (even ones that happen to be on Steam already, such as Sims 3).

http://penny-arcade.com/report/article/the-humble-bundle-tea...

You could always just scale your payment by how many of the games you can get on steam.

Considering games one already owns and games one doesn't want, that's what not purchasing this bundle is for me.

A great way to make Steam a monopoly where every consumer will lose.

How does Origin solve this problem for me?

Aside from the ideological reasons for not installing the Origin client, are there others? I'm wary of clients such as these installing loads of additional software and wondering if the Origin client is guilty of the same?

Not a risk I am willing to take, no matter how good the deal may seem. What is very sad (for me anyway since I only want The Sims) is that the Sims is available on Steam, yet there will not be a Steam unlock code for it.

I NEVER install Origin games on my PC, and this won't change this...

The same also applies to that Ubisoft weird thingy too.

I actually have Origin installed on my laptop that my SO uses. She loves The Sims 3 that I had bought a retail copy of. I later bought a Steam copy on a sale just for convenience sake of not needing the disc. The problem came in when I wanted to play a Steam game but she wanted to play The Sims 3 on the laptop. Since I had a retail copy, I just activated the key on Origin (something I could not do on Steam) and now she can play with all the convenience of digital delivery but not impact my gaming time by making me log out of Steam.

That's a perfect use case for Origin, in my mind :)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.