Skip to content

Comment on Relationships between Depression and High Intellectual Potential (2012)parent

Comments

I feel that statements like that belittle actual depression, which best to my knowledge is not something that you can pop into or out from that trivially.

I feel that statements like that are a working out of ideas out loud, with a community, and show a thoughtfulness and curiosity that deserves encouraging amongst humans. If you disagree with an idea, show evidence rather than trying to shame people into silence.

It's not the idea I'm disagreeing with, but the wording used to express it. More specifically the use of word "depression" to refer a condition that does not seem very "serious".

The problem with words like depression is that they really do have many meanings.

Depressing yourself is incredibly easy. If you don't believe me try thinking about Global warming, Poverty, War... you get the idea.

It's getting out of depression that's difficult. Otherwise people would go to the doctor to complain that they're not getting depressed enough, wouldn't they? There is such thing as not being sad enough. It's very rare that someone has unipolar mania, but it's common in bipolar disorder to fluctuate between the two extremes.

Maybe it's just mood alteration. It does take a lot of effort.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.