Skip to content

Comment on Tim Cook tells Congress why Apple won’t move $100 billion back homeparent

Comments

Well, corporations use resources that cannot be pinned to a single individual. The example that comes to mind would be putting out trash for the city to collect[1].

[1] I realize that companies pay separately, or use private collection in many cases. It's just an example of a company using a resource that can be (and in some cases is) paid for by taxes.

Probably there should be a resource tax, not profit tax?

How do you efficiently administer a road tax[1]? How do you measure a company's use of the military defense of a nation? The police protection that makes their locality safe for business in the first place? What about the nearby public park that attracts families who frequently go to a nearby ice cream shop? What about the fact that the local bar attracts people who get into fights on the sidewalk?

[1]Gas taxes are obviously not the answer.

How would this work? 20% every time you buy or something? Or targeted on things that are scarce or a limited (eg higher tax on oil than lettuce)? It seems to me that targeted taxes end up encouraging elaborate workarounds - this is a problem.

Yes, and the utility companies are extremely efficient collectors of that kind of tax.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.