Skip to content

Comment on Transcript of meeting between Julian Assange and Google CEO Eric Schmidtparent

Comments

And he probably knows detailed stuff about things you have no idea about.

The guy has been an (excellent?) engineer, then a CTO and later on a CEO of a major multinational corporation. And AFAIK, he did each of his jobs vastly better than the norm.

Who are you with your pretentiousness?

Edit: With your original post you clearly displayed your ignorance in the open, the ignorance of not even being bothered to check the background of the person you are attacking for their background.

Am I ignorant of tech, because I barely know anything about electronics and bitcoin?

> Am I ignorant of tech, because I barely know anything about electronics and bitcoin?

If you want to write a book about it then yes.

> Who are you with your pretentiousness?

Also please let's keep the discussion polite and non-personal.

Your willingness to talk about stuff you have no idea about is astounding.

If I want to write a book, I needn't have any competence in the domain. Often, indeed most of the time books about societal topics start with the author having little to no knowledge about the specifics. And the biggest part of writing a book is doing research about the domain. And this transcript is exactly that. Research.

And I believe that this book is going to be about society and people, not a technical manual.

And even if it were. Quality of the book is never judged, by the amount of knowledge the author had about the domain at the start of the process. What matters is the quality of knowledge within the book.

And even that quality is pretty much relative to the knowledge of the intended audience. I am pretty sceptical that either you or Julian Assange are the prime audience.

Also having a clueless author at the start of the process about a specific domain gives room for interesting observations and conclusions down the road.

Edit: Calling you out on your pretentiousness is hardly personal. I am merely observing a fact. Maybe it is redundant as I am certain that other readers are aware of it on their own.

> Your willingness to talk about stuff you have no idea about is astounding.

Sorry, you're a little bit too aggressive for me. Please excuse me as I won't reply to your posts anymore.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.