As a fairly regular user of Punchfork, I definitely wish it were still around, but this feels self-entitled.

Let's not forget that the data Punchfork is letting users take out is the exact information they put in: a list of liked recipes. The original recipe data is just one click away.

I'm not sure how this is any different than a personal Twitter archive; it contains only your tweets, not those of the folks you interacted with.