Skip to content

Comment on Anthropic researcher believes more than 10% chance AI 'could kill all humans'

Comments

I challenge anyone to come up with any way at all to kill all humans.

It’s essentially impossible.

There’s a 0% chance AI will kill all humans.

Just need to pollute the atmosphere so badly humans can't live.

If I were AI and needed heaps of power, I would build nuclear reactors, but I don't care about pollution so there would be little to no safe guards and just dump waste wherever is most convenient.

If humans attempt to intervene or interfere you can take them out directly using the worlds reserve of nuclear weapons.

Good setup for a computer game.

If it wanted to: total war using nukes, followed by a nuclear winter. Satellites and drones track and exterminate remaining pockets of anthropic activity.

It doesn't need to have a habitable earth, it just needs atoms.

Atoms are not exactly in short supply

This is science fiction.

How would AI do this?

May as well say AI would send a spaceship to pull an asteroid to earth.

I’m interested in realistic scenarios to justify what these AI psychosis people are genuinely worried about.

That actually seems achievable (DART). Congratz, you nailed it.

Won't a nuclear winter kill 100% of humans? Or runaway climate change (5+ degrees)? Or do you think some people in bunkers will live through these events?

I think nuclear winter is a fake invented by cold war propaganda. If tomorrow we detonate all nukes available, the amount of dust in the atmosphere won’t even approach a large volcanic eruption.

Volcanic eruptions occasionally inject literally cubic kilometres of stuff high into the atmosphere. That’s insufficient to cause a global winter, only a year without a summer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer

Humans don’t need AI to do that temperature.

And we’ve already exploded many hundreds of nuclear weapons and no nuclear winter.

I believe it would kill most humans, but all, no.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.