Skip to content

Comment on We could save petabytes of cache storage with Zstandard and Pingora

Comments

One thing that bothered me enough to comment on: "transcoding" doesn't seem like the right term in this context. "Encode/decode" is technically correct, but "compress/decompress" would have made the intent much clearer.

Transcoding is generally used within the context of audio or video codecs, to convert a file from one format to another. And usually from one lossy format to another (eg: not raw uncompressed YUV420, YUV422P video or whatever that is stored in a lossless compression format). It's not clear to me why they're using it in this web page.

Yeah, the following sentence in TFA is weird:

Transcoding does not mean compressing everything. Images, video, and fonts are usually compressed already.

It's because they're already lossily compressed that, precisely, they're the typical targets for transcoding.

EDIT: oops, wrote lossless instead of lossy, sorry about that

Additionally modern fonts are normally vector point data, no? So there's plenty of opportunity for shrinking file size by lossless compession. But I don't think that's what they're talking about here?

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.