Skip to content

Comment on Adafruit USB Type C CC Resistor Fixer

Comments

Anyone in test for the domain able to attest that formal USB compliance verification would have detected the design defect that this hack resolves?

It absolutely would. This is an "didn't even read a 5-paragraph AI summary of the spec" level of a design defect.

If you need this fix, it will literally refuse to work with any spec-compliant USB-C device on the other side of a C-C cable. No way to miss it.

Wonder if there are USB C cable testers that detects this.

In practice, most if not all networking/hardware department carries a ethernet cable tester but somehow not true for USB cables.

It's not the cable that's the problem here; it's the device you're plugging into the cable.

You don't need a cable tester to detect this problem; just plug the device into a spec-compliant USB-C power brick with a USB-C cable and see if it fails to charge.

You don't need a tester to detect this (and it's not about cables).

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.