Comment on ATProto spaces: A new extension to ATProto that enables non-public dataparentComments−inigyou19dWho would you ask besides the author's PDS though? Would every relay have a cached copy of all private data, but only give it out after checking auth? That's not a very safe design - what if my relay doesn't check?−chokolad19dspaces do not use relays. The sync protocol is pull from PDS. https://dholms.leaflet.pub/3mqtqvjidqs2p−inigyou18dSo it's a central server and doesn't benefit from being ATP as it can be anything you want.
Comments
Who would you ask besides the author's PDS though? Would every relay have a cached copy of all private data, but only give it out after checking auth? That's not a very safe design - what if my relay doesn't check?
spaces do not use relays. The sync protocol is pull from PDS. https://dholms.leaflet.pub/3mqtqvjidqs2p
So it's a central server and doesn't benefit from being ATP as it can be anything you want.