Again, by using differentials instead of derivatives, we have transformed a number of processes that students find unintuitive
into a single process where the intuition is supplied by the student’s knowledge of algebra.
Ah yes. Algebra. The subject all students love dearly. If only we could get students to love and appreciate calculus as much they love algebra!
I have a hard time even imagining an article that is more disconnected from the reality of teaching calculus to tiny humans.
So you are saying that disconnecting calculus from algebra improves the average student's calculus ability? What planet are you from?
We spend a lot of time and effort teaching kids how to do algebra, and how to manipulate equations algebraically. By the time they get anywhere near calculus, they know how to do this. Thus, rather than trying to build a whole mathematical world from scratch, the idea is to *build on what they are already practicing* rather than try to drop them in a wild, uninhabited country and say "good luck".
What's funny is the number of adult parents of students who tell me they took four semesters of calculus in college and *never understood what it was about*. This is the real crisis I'm trying to solve. We are teaching. People are learning just enough to pass tests, but aren't internalizing any of it.
I work with engineers on a daily basis. Many never fully grasped what calculus was trying to teach. But they are extremely fluent in algebra. The reason for this disconnect is that no one bothered connecting them strongly.
Comments
Ah yes. Algebra. The subject all students love dearly. If only we could get students to love and appreciate calculus as much they love algebra!
I have a hard time even imagining an article that is more disconnected from the reality of teaching calculus to tiny humans.
So you are saying that disconnecting calculus from algebra improves the average student's calculus ability? What planet are you from?
We spend a lot of time and effort teaching kids how to do algebra, and how to manipulate equations algebraically. By the time they get anywhere near calculus, they know how to do this. Thus, rather than trying to build a whole mathematical world from scratch, the idea is to *build on what they are already practicing* rather than try to drop them in a wild, uninhabited country and say "good luck".
What's funny is the number of adult parents of students who tell me they took four semesters of calculus in college and *never understood what it was about*. This is the real crisis I'm trying to solve. We are teaching. People are learning just enough to pass tests, but aren't internalizing any of it.
I work with engineers on a daily basis. Many never fully grasped what calculus was trying to teach. But they are extremely fluent in algebra. The reason for this disconnect is that no one bothered connecting them strongly.