Github/Gitea issue with feature request; typically not slop
Github/Gitea PR with AI-implimented feature; typically slop
The issue is almost always drive-by contributions. A lot of programmers don't care about dependency creep, SLOC management, SDLC nicities, fragile CI/CD or multiplatform testing. Many FOSS maintainers and core contributors have a much higher standard for what they're willing to merge, and therefore reject slop judiciously. Same goes for one-man-band vibe coding outfits that want to ship a half-assed "native" app and charge money for it. Most of these people don't understand what the industry considers standard, even with AI helping them.
FWIW, there were slop PRs even before AI. Famously Paragon's NTFS driver was so bad that Linux refused to merge it because the costs outweighed any potential benefits. It ultimately came down to a difference in culture between FOSS and closed-source development.
Comments
Github/Gitea issue with feature request; typically not slop
Github/Gitea PR with AI-implimented feature; typically slop
The issue is almost always drive-by contributions. A lot of programmers don't care about dependency creep, SLOC management, SDLC nicities, fragile CI/CD or multiplatform testing. Many FOSS maintainers and core contributors have a much higher standard for what they're willing to merge, and therefore reject slop judiciously. Same goes for one-man-band vibe coding outfits that want to ship a half-assed "native" app and charge money for it. Most of these people don't understand what the industry considers standard, even with AI helping them.
FWIW, there were slop PRs even before AI. Famously Paragon's NTFS driver was so bad that Linux refused to merge it because the costs outweighed any potential benefits. It ultimately came down to a difference in culture between FOSS and closed-source development.