> when that link is posted to a non-porn subreddit it's more of a problem.
I think that's a seperate concern. Moderators delete bad posts, and the spam filter operates on a per-subreddit basis.
> Reddit is better as a community rather than a dump for links
I'd agree its certainly different as a community than say Digg, but I'm not sure if its for the better because reddit freezes out content creators from using Reddit to syndicate their content.
People posting links to stuff copied onto a pay-per-click image sharing site are pretty far down the food chain. What worries me is that essentially content-creators can't use Reddit without becoming a part of Reddit's community and 'paying their dues' as it is.
Reddit's mods and users have banned or severely punished even major newspapers who wanted to just post their articles on Reddit, and not become Redditors themselves.
> What worries me is that essentially content-creators can't use Reddit without becoming a part of Reddit's community and 'paying their dues' as it is.
> Reddit's mods and users have banned or severely punished even major newspapers who wanted to just post their articles on Reddit, and not become Redditors themselves.
A lot of those content creators toe the line between marketing their content on Reddit, and spamming it.
I have a moderately high karma on Reddit, and sometimes get private messages asking me to help people get submissions upvoted in r/politics, and other subreddits. It almost always sounds shady, and I almost always reply with the same thing - post quality content relevant to the subreddit with good titles.
Newspapers trying to post content to reddit without "paying their dues" is like trying to get free advertising. If you have to pay for ads with money, what's wrong with paying for reddit views with "dues" and becoming part of the community?
Essentially the only way to pay your dues in Reddit is to post content apart from your own, and make bunches of comments to prove that you are 'real person'.
That's problematic because content creators don't want to help the competition, and they have real jobs making stuff so don't want to make reddit their part time job.
Advertisement comes with certain guarantees---pay X amount and you get Y amount of impressions or clicks. Becoming part of a community has no guarantee of success, and even once successful Reddit can always turn against you if they view your posting 1 article per day as "spam" because you work for the newspaper who makes the article.
Comments
> when that link is posted to a non-porn subreddit it's more of a problem.
I think that's a seperate concern. Moderators delete bad posts, and the spam filter operates on a per-subreddit basis.
> Reddit is better as a community rather than a dump for links
I'd agree its certainly different as a community than say Digg, but I'm not sure if its for the better because reddit freezes out content creators from using Reddit to syndicate their content.
People posting links to stuff copied onto a pay-per-click image sharing site are pretty far down the food chain. What worries me is that essentially content-creators can't use Reddit without becoming a part of Reddit's community and 'paying their dues' as it is.
Reddit's mods and users have banned or severely punished even major newspapers who wanted to just post their articles on Reddit, and not become Redditors themselves.
> What worries me is that essentially content-creators can't use Reddit without becoming a part of Reddit's community and 'paying their dues' as it is. > Reddit's mods and users have banned or severely punished even major newspapers who wanted to just post their articles on Reddit, and not become Redditors themselves.
A lot of those content creators toe the line between marketing their content on Reddit, and spamming it.
I have a moderately high karma on Reddit, and sometimes get private messages asking me to help people get submissions upvoted in r/politics, and other subreddits. It almost always sounds shady, and I almost always reply with the same thing - post quality content relevant to the subreddit with good titles.
Newspapers trying to post content to reddit without "paying their dues" is like trying to get free advertising. If you have to pay for ads with money, what's wrong with paying for reddit views with "dues" and becoming part of the community?
Essentially the only way to pay your dues in Reddit is to post content apart from your own, and make bunches of comments to prove that you are 'real person'.
That's problematic because content creators don't want to help the competition, and they have real jobs making stuff so don't want to make reddit their part time job.
Advertisement comes with certain guarantees---pay X amount and you get Y amount of impressions or clicks. Becoming part of a community has no guarantee of success, and even once successful Reddit can always turn against you if they view your posting 1 article per day as "spam" because you work for the newspaper who makes the article.