Skip to content

Comment on World-First 'Super Alloy' Could Transform the Way Metals Are Madeparent

Comments

Absolutely nobody is using an expensive novel alloy for 2GPa compressive strength. A 2GPa tensile strength, depending on various other factors such as corrosion resistance and thermal properties, could however be very interesting. (The strongest bulk steel alloys generally peak at ~3.6GPa tensile, which is approximately their theoretical maximum, but there are a lot of applications where steel simply can't be used. Nickel superalloys are typically 0.9 to 1.1GPa UTS.)

That's true, but it's still factor and if price comes down having that much compressive strength at your disposal could be an interesting choice for supertall skyscrapers.

2GPa isn't a super-high value for compressive strength. Regular tool steels can exceed it. Technical ceramics routinely exceed it. If you normalize to weight, various cement/concrete formulations can also surpass it.

Also, the price of a Ta-Hf-Zr-Nb-Ti alloy isn't especially elastic. Tantalum in particular is an unavoidably expensive element.

I'll grant that what would be exceptional is a metal with a >2GPa compressive strength, a >2GPa tensile strength, and decent damage tolerance and ductility. I don't think that this paper describes a material with that outstanding combination of properties, though -- it's much more likely to describe a simple brittle material.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.