"followed up"...

he was extradited from 400 miles away in a different state, had never been to florida, and had timesheets from working at his job at the time.

how did that craziness even pull him into the lineup?

Honestly, at some point this kind of tool is going to find LOTS of similar people from a pool of 350,000,000

We need a new term for this, maybe likeness-fishing.