Skip to content

Comment on Ask HN: Are orbital data centers possible / a good idea?

Comments

What problem is solved by putting a data center in orbit?

You can solve all of them far cheaper and easier on land.

Energy cost can be theoretically lower than on earth IF launch costs and additional hardware costs are low enough. Because solar is about 5x better on space than on earth. That's basically it.

For fun, I ran some numbers here.

If we wanted to launch the Stratos Hyperscale AI Data Center, which will take 40,000 acres of land, to space, we're looking at roughly 3 million tons of equipment, or 3 billion kilograms. SpaceX charges $1520 per kilogram, so it would be about $4.5T to launch all of that into orbit. We'll just assume the space station already exists and labor is free to hook it up, given that we've already hit the annual budget for the US federal government in launch fees. And it'll take about 47,000 launches to get the equipment there, or roughly 300 years.

What problem is solved by putting a data center in orbit?

Applying standard financial metrics (do they make money? Will they ever? What valuation does that justify?) to certain companies.

The problem of the hype-train starting to cool is the only real problem it solved or will ever solve

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.