And one would argue without actually focusing on Linux the kernel and Linux distro on top for the average user, they're just funding server FOSS for use by fat companies
That’s explicitly their mission, though! They’re a trade organization that advances member interests, not a public interest nonprofit.
(In effect, they’re a coordinating body for fat companies. They do indeed fund things in those companies’ interests, but they do it with corporate money.)
They’re a trade organization that advances member interests, not a public interest nonprofit.
Maybe they should say that with a huge banner on their website then. How many people give them money thinking it's for the good of FOSS in the idealistic sense?
Very few, I think. I had to search for their “donate” page, and it says explicitly that donations are not tax deductible.
(FWICT, the overwhelming majority of LF’s money comes from conference fees, and the biggest chunk of the rest comes from corporate dues. Private donations don’t appear to be a significant portion of their income.)
Comments
one could also argue that software that build on top of it create the ecosystem that can drive linux adoption.
This critique is myopic.
And one would argue without actually focusing on Linux the kernel and Linux distro on top for the average user, they're just funding server FOSS for use by fat companies
That’s explicitly their mission, though! They’re a trade organization that advances member interests, not a public interest nonprofit.
(In effect, they’re a coordinating body for fat companies. They do indeed fund things in those companies’ interests, but they do it with corporate money.)
Maybe they should say that with a huge banner on their website then. How many people give them money thinking it's for the good of FOSS in the idealistic sense?
Very few, I think. I had to search for their “donate” page, and it says explicitly that donations are not tax deductible.
(FWICT, the overwhelming majority of LF’s money comes from conference fees, and the biggest chunk of the rest comes from corporate dues. Private donations don’t appear to be a significant portion of their income.)
Agreed - without user-space, developer and deployment tools, there's not much for the kernel to do. 3% on the kernel might even seem overly high.