Skip to content

Comment on Why isn't AMD's MI300X competitive?parent

Comments

Has this changed, If I want to go hands on with development using pytorch or whatever is used now, would you recommend an AMD card?

Genuine question, I have not followed this topic closely for years :)

Short answer, no.

There are better learning resources and a better ecosystem available around Nvidia cards & software (cuda).

Long answer, it depends. It will add more challenges and require significantly more effort (even outside the GPU programming itself, debugging toolchain etc. is a somewhat separate skill). The smaller/less mature ecosystem also means you will have less examples to look at for references.

RDNA is a whole different (and much poorer supported) animal than CDNA. As someone with extensive experience in both, if you're asking the question, then, no.

(If you're just looking to learn, use the free Kaggle/Google Cola T4s/TPUs to get started.)

Still rocking a 3090 so can't speak from experience but general vibe around simple at home inference seems like it has improved (esp since both vulkan and rocm are now viable paths on newer cards).

development using pytorch

Would probably still play it nvidia safe for more adventurous stuff than token generation even if it has improved

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.