Comment on AI prefers resumes written by itself: Self-preferencing in Algorithmic HiringComments−ytpeteOP4mo- When GPT 4 was asked to evaluate resume executive summaries, it preferred ones written by GPT over human-written ones > 93% of the time.- Similar "bias" was exhibited by other models including LLaMA 3.3 and Deepseek v3.- Even when human annotators judged the human-written summary to be higher quality, leading LLMs still preferred their own writing 67-82% of the time.- Preference was stronger in larger models.- In several cases, LLMs also prefer their own writing over that of other LLMs.There's a pretty decent longer summary in this thread where I first heard about the article: https://x.com/heynavtoor/status/2048088874686300431
Comments
- When GPT 4 was asked to evaluate resume executive summaries, it preferred ones written by GPT over human-written ones > 93% of the time.
- Similar "bias" was exhibited by other models including LLaMA 3.3 and Deepseek v3.
- Even when human annotators judged the human-written summary to be higher quality, leading LLMs still preferred their own writing 67-82% of the time.
- Preference was stronger in larger models.
- In several cases, LLMs also prefer their own writing over that of other LLMs.
There's a pretty decent longer summary in this thread where I first heard about the article: https://x.com/heynavtoor/status/2048088874686300431