Skip to content

Comment on Moleskine's AI Lord of the Rings collection can only mockparent

Comments

The person prompting the AI is not the artist.

I don't think that the parent comment argued that they are, but okay.

If I were to go to Fiverr and tell a person to create an image for me, would you consider me the creator of that image?

Can you consider a movie director to be the creator of a movie? They are just telling other people what to do.

I don't think that the parent comment argued that they are, but okay.

I think they did. They specifically said how a new tool is available and putting things into reach for people that previously wasn't. In the context about creating art, that reads to me like they do mean that prompters are considered the creators.

Can you consider a movie director to be the creator of a movie? They are just telling other people what to do.

If the "only" thing the director is doing, in the most literal sense, is directing then no, I don't.

I'm not an expert in media production though but from the sparse amount of interviews I have seen a lot also write the scripts and are involved in a lot more than just directing.

I think ultimately this is just something we disagree on :)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.