Skip to content

Comment on 5NF and Database Designparent

Comments

Frankly I don't think that overcounting is solved by normalizing, because it's easy to write an overcounting SQL query over perfectly normalized data.

I tried to explain the real cause of overcounting in my "Modern Guide to SQL JOINs":

https://kb.databasedesignbook.com/posts/sql-joins/#understan...

I'll go one further and say that if you're reaching for DISTINCT and you have joins, you may have joined the data the wrong way. It's not a RULE, but it's ALWAYS a 'smell' when I see a query that uses DISTINCT to shove away duplicate matches. I always add a comment for the exceptions.

Great read, thank you!

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.