Graphics isn't everything, gameplay is.

And they both suck. Geaphics is either too realstic or too of "small child" variety. Nothing in between.

And gameplay: There is a lot of interference with the player: i want a shooter, not an RPG (wolfenstein). I want to build cities, not fight to collect stupid items (Anno 2205). And wait hours for the game to download and then, one per week, the same to update.