Skip to content

Comment on DHS Says DHS-Certified Real IDs Too Unreliable to Confirm U.S. Citizenshipparent

Comments

I mean i literally was forced to get a real ID since i was in the US for more than 10 days (you can't drive on a foreign license longer than that in California and they hand out real ID licenses now).

It's no trouble to get a real ID licence as a non-US citizen. They literally have a process for this.

This article seems mind boggingly stupid. They are trying to create drama out of something that isn't there.

I mean i literally was forced to get a real ID since i was in the US for more than 10 days (you can't drive on a foreign license longer than that in California and they hand out real ID licenses now).

If you intend to reside in California, you need a California license within 10 days of establishing residency (assuming you drive); but if you're just visiting for a month, I think you can use your out of state or foreign license. If you've got some authoritative reference that states a temporary visitor (less than 6-month) to California needs a CA license, I'd like to see that...

Indeed a resident non-citizen who's required to get a licence in 10 days. A very common thing in the valley.

Which is why this article is going at the wrong point. Real ID is meant for citizen and non-citizen alike.

But not for people who don't have legal permanent residence

Sorry, citizens being detained in handcuffs for hours on suspicion of not being a citizen, simply for being Latino, despite carrying a federally-approved ID, is in fact drama.

You got your REAL ID because you were legally allowed to be here. They wouldn't have issued it otherwise. DHS approved your REAL ID so they have no reason to assume that if you a have a valid one you're not allowed to be here

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.