Skip to content

Comment on Proof Claimed for Deep Connection between Prime Numbers

Comments

Relevant meta-commentary on the proof by Marty Weissman and Minhyong Kim:

http://mathoverflow.net/questions/106560/philosophy-behind-m...

One way to deal with an overzealous mod:

Such a great answer proves that the question was worth asking. – Olivier 2 days ago

@Olivier: while I agree with your comment regarding the answer, I woould like to add that your inference regarding this particular question to me comes close to saying: the great and heroic work of the fire-fighters prove that it was worth setting the house on fire. – quid 2 days ago

On MathOverflow, though, it is possible to edit the original house so that it is no longer inflammatory, while still recording the work of the firefighter. – Terry Tao 2 days ago

[edit: formatting]

The fact that we have a fkg Fields medallist having to deal with overzealous mods makes me sad.

Those answers read like Klingon to me :/

This link was already posted in this thread. And as I mentioned there, it wasn't Gowers but Martin Weissman who wrote the first answer. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4503359

Edited to correct the attribution. Thanks for pointing out!

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.