Comment on Problems in AI alignment: A scale modelComments−benlivengood1yhttps://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ is the essay that crystalizes the reasons that Selection and Markets are not the forces we want to be aligning AI (or much else).In short (it is a very long article) fitness is not the same as goodness (by human standards) and so selection pressure will squeeze out goodness in favor of fitness, across all environments and niches, in the long run.−hamburgaOP1yWhy can’t we infuse Selection with Goodness? We’re the ones doing the selecting. We’ve selected out things like chattel slavery, for example.(Disclaimer: fell asleep after 10 minutes of reading the SSC post last night. I know it’s part of the HN Canon and perhaps I’m missing something)
Comments
https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ is the essay that crystalizes the reasons that Selection and Markets are not the forces we want to be aligning AI (or much else).
In short (it is a very long article) fitness is not the same as goodness (by human standards) and so selection pressure will squeeze out goodness in favor of fitness, across all environments and niches, in the long run.
Why can’t we infuse Selection with Goodness? We’re the ones doing the selecting. We’ve selected out things like chattel slavery, for example.
(Disclaimer: fell asleep after 10 minutes of reading the SSC post last night. I know it’s part of the HN Canon and perhaps I’m missing something)