Skip to content

Comment on Show HN: I built a knife steel comparison tool

Comments

[Maybe attach the screenshot here if HN allows, or link to it]

I think the AI intended for you to edit out this part?

Shhh, I like those placeholders as dead giveaways that content was AI-produced. Don’t call too much attention to them or we’ll lose this way of identifying slop :)

I'm fine with ai slop if it provides value, the value here being questionable, because now I don't know if the values in the comparison are fact checked or hallucinations.

I suspect they're hallucinated. As a random spot check: https://new.knife.day/item/spyderco-paramilitary-2

"The Spyderco Paramilitary 2 is a tactical knife with a 3.44 inch blade. The knife is made in USA of CPM S35VN steel."

It's a real knife, and the blade length checks out (to two significant figures), but the manufacturer spec sheet says S45VN steel. Also the actual name is "Para Military® 2".

https://www.spyderco.com/catalog/details/C81GS2/2090

A problem with choosing that specific knife for a spot check is that it has been made in many different steels in various special editions, sprint runs, and dealer exclusives. Here's one in S35VN:

https://www.spyderco.com/catalog/details/C81GBNBK2/Para-Mili...

p-s-vOP

this data is mostly scraped from a few large knife retailers, so should be accurate.

It's unusual for a large retailer to not use the official name of a product

Not in this particular case. Out of the 5 knife retailers I just checked, 4 use Paramilitary in their listings. Only one included a space.

p-s-vOP

shrug, if you search around youll see that isnt true

Fair enough, I do see it listed under that name on some sites, and there appears to be a S35VN variant too

I thought, maybe OP had it in their draft for long and directly pasted it.

p-s-vOP

hahah oops, i did use AI to produce this hacker news post :)

Why?

p-s-vOP

it writes a better summary than I can

(We've edited that bit out from the text above now.)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.