You have that website, but no one is gonna use it because there are thousands of better, more populated alternatives

Might be true, don't know until we test, get feedback, iterate, etc.

mostly a dick

On that I'll agree ;) realistic part is relative - you're also just guessing what 'people' want and assume everyone is like you. Based on the above assertion I hope not. Time may prove you right or wrong - no harm in testing an idea.