I used to operate a home network all enterprisey and public Internetish, with VLAN, inter-VLAN routing & firewalling, a public IPv4 on the outside of an OPNsense router, and a Hurricane Electric free public /48 block (through their tunnel service) so that every node has at least one public IP... I ditched it all - I now operate a flat LAN with the ISP's standard box - and Tailscale everywhere. The only major functional difference is that services hosted on the LAN require an external reverse proxy (which I run on a free Oracle Cloud Ampere host)...
As a bonus, my family can call the ISP's tech support if anything dysfunction while I'm traveling: my self-hosting crap is perfectly independent from the ISP's standard service. And wait, there's more - I can add services anywhere, such as a backup server at my parent's, regardless of their configuration and with no impact.
So yes, Tailscale all the things... I'm nostalgic for the IPv6 flat end-to-end dream but, in our world of ubiquitous IPv4 NAT horrors, Tailscale functionally surpasses it.
Comments
I used to operate a home network all enterprisey and public Internetish, with VLAN, inter-VLAN routing & firewalling, a public IPv4 on the outside of an OPNsense router, and a Hurricane Electric free public /48 block (through their tunnel service) so that every node has at least one public IP... I ditched it all - I now operate a flat LAN with the ISP's standard box - and Tailscale everywhere. The only major functional difference is that services hosted on the LAN require an external reverse proxy (which I run on a free Oracle Cloud Ampere host)...
As a bonus, my family can call the ISP's tech support if anything dysfunction while I'm traveling: my self-hosting crap is perfectly independent from the ISP's standard service. And wait, there's more - I can add services anywhere, such as a backup server at my parent's, regardless of their configuration and with no impact.
So yes, Tailscale all the things... I'm nostalgic for the IPv6 flat end-to-end dream but, in our world of ubiquitous IPv4 NAT horrors, Tailscale functionally surpasses it.