Skip to content

Comment on AI focused on brain regions recreates what you're looking at (2024)parent

Comments

I think the distinction you're drawing between "the central nervous system" and "the brain" is mistaken here -- the brain is part of the CNS. This kind of reflex basically has to involve the brain b/c it involves both the visual system and the motor system i.e. there's not a fast path from the retina to moving your appendages etc that doesn't include the brain.

The "fully process" part is part of the story though -- e.g. perhaps some reactions use the dorsal stream based on peripheral vision while ventral stream is still waiting on a saccade and focus to get higher resolution foveal signals. But though these different pathways in the brain operate at different speeds, they're both still very much in the brain.

Some touch-based reflexes might avoid the higher parts of the brain though no?

Yeah I think there are multiple documented cases of this, where especially well-practiced motor-plans seem to be 'pushed down', and if they're interrupted, correction can start faster than a round trip to the brain.

In this article you can see a typical and a "broken" "visual to amygdala fear shortcuts" (the "broken" is MRI of the famous climber Honnold)

https://assets.nautil.us/10086_6412121cbb2dc2cb9e460cfee7046...

https://nautil.us/the-strange-brain-of-the-worlds-greatest-s...

(the path is from the back of the head (V5?) where the visual nerve comes into brain)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.