Skip to content

Comment on π0.5: A VLA with open-world generalization

Comments

I'm just a layman, but I can't see this design scaling. It's way too slow and "hard" for fine motor tasks like cleaning up a kitchen or being anywhere around humans, really.

I think the future is in "softer" type of robots that can sense whether their robot fingers are pushing a cabinet door (or if it's facing resistance) and adjust accordingly. A quick google search shows this example (animated render) which is closer to what I imagine the ultimate solution will be: https://compliance-robotics.com/compliance-industry/

Human flesh is way too squishy for us to allow hard tools to interface with it, unless the human is in control. The difference between a blunt weapon and the robot from TFA is that the latter is very slow and on wheels.

The development here is primarily in the model. If someone invents the 'brains' a robot needs to do useful domestic tasks then there will suddenly be a lot of incentive to build the right body for it.

Right, but ISTM that building the right body is a much harder problem than people are willing to admit.

Software isn't constrained by the harsh truths of physical reality.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.