Skip to content

Comment on Mass market non-fiction has bad incentivesparent

Comments

There's non-fiction (historical accounts and pop-sci explainers) and there's non-fiction (here's how you ought to behave.)

Obviously SPQR, but also Bad Blood is a historical account, and it's interesting.

Most business books are of the "here's how you ought to behave" variety. Most of these were written to win the author consulting gigs. The vast majority are formulaic and bland. Also, to hit a publisher's wordcount/shelf-space targets, they're always heavily padded. 99.9% of them would be better off in much more concise bullet-point format.

Of course there are a lot of edge cases and books that don't fit neatly into any category. And there are some books, like the Hagakure, Meditations, and the Bible itself, which started off as clear-cut examples of "here's how you ought to behave" but later became historically important.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.