Skip to content

Comment on Show HN: New search engine and free-FOIA-by-fax-via-web for US veteran recordsparent

Comments

As a person, not a Veteran, I totally agree. This data should not be public domain. Definitely only accessible to family members (if at all).

Having obtained my father’s military records, I can definitely say that I’m glad these weren’t online, searchable. Via those records I learnt much concerning my father and I’m glad I obtained them.

To get those records, I had to prove I was his son, that my father was indeed deceased and that he hadn’t said/written anything to prevent me from having his records. That should be the minimum (IMHO) for obtaining such records. This wasn’t in the USA though.

The military uses the gun of the taxman to force us to pay for them. If they're going to put me in a tiny cage for not paying up while they're galavanting around the world drone striking brown people and us citizens the least I can get out of it is the records.

Most of the people in this database were drafted. I think you're angry at the wrong people.

This dump will give you the personal records of the rank and file. The “military” that you’re talking about is really congress and the president. It makes much more sense to go after the actions and communication of those folks than some grunts who gave their bodies shoveling shit for a chance at a future.

Maybe OP should be going after the politicians and corporations that have used government benefits. Where's that freely searchable database?

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.